Vacation rentals in Gardiners Island, NY

96 available vacation rental offers

airbnbBooking.comVrboExpediaSonderpricelineTripadvisorTrip.comHomestayHotels.comOrbitz

Choose the perfect vacation accommodation

Price per night

Up to $100$100 - 200From $200

Accommodation type

Vacation rentals

Rating

Excellent 9+Very good 8+Good 7+All ratings

Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Gardiners Island, NY

Classic Montauk Beach Cottage, Quick Walk to Beach and Town - Gardiners Island, NY

Classic Montauk Beach Cottage, Quick Walk to Beach and Town

Cottage, Gardiners Island

Classic Montauk Beach Cottage, Quick Walk to Beach and Town is a cottage in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About Classic Montauk Beach Cottage, Quick Walk to Beach and Town

Classic Montauk Beach Cottage, Quick Walk to Beach and Town is a cottage in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, parking, free parking, and heating.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $3,894.

From$413/night
Show
Newly Renovated 1 BR -1BA condo Last minute availability-discounted rate!!! - Gardiners Island, NY

Newly Renovated 1 BR -1BA condo Last minute availability-discounted rate!!!

Condo, Gardiners Island

Newly Renovated 1 BR -1BA condo Last minute availability-discounted rate!!! is a condo in Gardiners Island, with pool access, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers…

Read more

About Newly Renovated 1 BR -1BA condo Last minute availability-discounted rate!!!

Newly Renovated 1 BR -1BA condo Last minute availability-discounted rate!!! is a condo in Gardiners Island, with pool access, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, free wifi, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $3,921.

From$415/night
Show
Unit 1011: Studio | 1st Floor-Garden View | Starfish - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 1011: Studio | 1st Floor-Garden View | Starfish

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 1011: Studio · 1st Floor-Garden View · Starfish is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Unit 1011: Studio | 1st Floor-Garden View | Starfish

Unit 1011: Studio · 1st Floor-Garden View · Starfish is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and onsite parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,785.

From$453/night
Show
Unit 1012: Studio | 1st Floor-Garden View | Starfish - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 1012: Studio | 1st Floor-Garden View | Starfish

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 1012: Studio · 1st Floor-Garden View · Starfish is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Unit 1012: Studio | 1st Floor-Garden View | Starfish

Unit 1012: Studio · 1st Floor-Garden View · Starfish is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and onsite parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,785.

From$453/night
Show

Browse Waterfront Vacation Rentals in Gardiners Island, NY

Discover vacation rentals close to the coast, water, and beach areas around Gardiners Island, NY.

Montauk Royal Atlantic Beach Resort North Condo - Gardiners Island, NY

Montauk Royal Atlantic Beach Resort North Condo

Condo, Gardiners Island

Montauk Royal Atlantic Beach Resort North Condo is a condo in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between…

Read more

About Montauk Royal Atlantic Beach Resort North Condo

Montauk Royal Atlantic Beach Resort North Condo is a condo in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: ac, air conditioning, heating, and living room.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,152.

From$455/night
Show
Newly Renovated Montauk Oceanfront Condo- steps to Beach, Fishing, Golf, & Town! - Gardiners Island, NY

Newly Renovated Montauk Oceanfront Condo- steps to Beach, Fishing, Golf, & Town!

Condo, Gardiners Island

Newly Renovated Montauk Oceanfront Condo- steps to Beach, Fishing, Golf, & Town! is a condo in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives…

Read more

About Newly Renovated Montauk Oceanfront Condo- steps to Beach, Fishing, Golf, & Town!

Newly Renovated Montauk Oceanfront Condo- steps to Beach, Fishing, Golf, & Town! is a condo in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, pool, free wifi, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,757.

From$500/night
Show
Unit 1825: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View | Dunes East - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 1825: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View | Dunes East

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 1825: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View · Dunes East is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers…

Read more

About Unit 1825: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View | Dunes East

Unit 1825: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View · Dunes East is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, parking, onsite parking, and washer.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,036.

From$727/night
Show
Unit 2023: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Bay View | Court Side - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 2023: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Bay View | Court Side

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 2023: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Bay View · Court Side is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Unit 2023: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Bay View | Court Side

Unit 2023: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Bay View · Court Side is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, parking, onsite parking, and washer.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,360.

From$727/night
Show

Browse Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Gardiners Island, NY

Add a pool to the search when you want an easy place to cool off between outings.

Unit 1712: 1-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Ocean Front | Ocean Edge - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 1712: 1-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Ocean Front | Ocean Edge

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 1712: 1-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Ocean Front · Ocean Edge is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base…

Read more

About Unit 1712: 1-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Ocean Front | Ocean Edge

Unit 1712: 1-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Ocean Front · Ocean Edge is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and onsite parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $6,466.

From$626/night
Show
Unit 1714: 1-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Ocean Front | Ocean Edge - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 1714: 1-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Ocean Front | Ocean Edge

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 1714: 1-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Ocean Front · Ocean Edge is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Unit 1714: 1-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Ocean Front | Ocean Edge

Unit 1714: 1-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Ocean Front · Ocean Edge is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, free wifi, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $6,466.

From$626/night
Show
Unit 1827: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View | Dunes East - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 1827: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View | Dunes East

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 1827: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View · Dunes East is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Unit 1827: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View | Dunes East

Unit 1827: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Partial Ocean View · Dunes East is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and onsite parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,360.

From$727/night
Show
Unit 2022: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Bay View | Court Side - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 2022: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Bay View | Court Side

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 2022: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Bay View · Court Side is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Unit 2022: 1-Bedroom with Loft | 2nd Floor-Bay View | Court Side

Unit 2022: 1-Bedroom with Loft · 2nd Floor-Bay View · Court Side is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and onsite parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,360.

From$727/night
Show

Best Gardiners Island, NY vacation rentals with parking

Find vacation rentals that make arriving by car easier.

Cozy Hamptons Hideaway -10 minute car ride to Annual Hampton Film Festival - Gardiners Island, NY

Cozy Hamptons Hideaway -10 minute car ride to Annual Hampton Film Festival

Holiday Home, Gardiners Island

Cozy Hamptons Hideaway -10 minute car ride to Annual Hampton Film Festival is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About Cozy Hamptons Hideaway -10 minute car ride to Annual Hampton Film Festival

Cozy Hamptons Hideaway -10 minute car ride to Annual Hampton Film Festival is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and free parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $6,831.

From$729/night
Show
Spacious and cozy home in heart of Springs, EH - Gardiners Island, NY

Spacious and cozy home in heart of Springs, EH

Holiday Home, Gardiners Island

Spacious and cozy home in heart of Springs, EH is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area,…

Read more

About Spacious and cozy home in heart of Springs, EH

Spacious and cozy home in heart of Springs, EH is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, gym, parking, and free parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,221.

From$771/night
Show
Beautiful Oceanfront views in the heart of Montauk. Sleeps up to 6. - Gardiners Island, NY

Beautiful Oceanfront views in the heart of Montauk. Sleeps up to 6.

Condo, Gardiners Island

Beautiful Oceanfront views in the heart of Montauk. Sleeps up to 6. is a condo in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Beautiful Oceanfront views in the heart of Montauk. Sleeps up to 6.

Beautiful Oceanfront views in the heart of Montauk. Sleeps up to 6. is a condo in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, parking, free parking, and washer.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,462.

From$779/night
Show
Unit 1211: Two-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Garden View | Love - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 1211: Two-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Garden View | Love

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 1211: Two-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Garden View · Love is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Unit 1211: Two-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Garden View | Love

Unit 1211: Two-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Garden View · Love is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with pool access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and onsite parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $8,324.

From$831/night
Show

Best Pet-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Gardiners Island, NY

Bring your pet along with stays that welcome four-legged travelers.

Charming Country Home sits on a 3-acre property in Bucolic Orient. - Gardiners Island, NY

Charming Country Home sits on a 3-acre property in Bucolic Orient.

Holiday Home, Gardiners Island

Charming Country Home sits on a 3-acre property in Bucolic Orient. is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About Charming Country Home sits on a 3-acre property in Bucolic Orient.

Charming Country Home sits on a 3-acre property in Bucolic Orient. is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, pet friendly, pets friendly, and kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $5,866.

From$645/night
Show
Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included. - Gardiners Island, NY

Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included.

Cottage, Gardiners Island

Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included. is a cottage in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included.

Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included. is a cottage in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pet friendly, pets friendly, kitchen, with kitchen, and beachfront.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $9,028.

From$950/night
Show
Peaceful 3-bedroom house in East Hampton - Gardiners Island, NY

Peaceful 3-bedroom house in East Hampton

Holiday Home, Gardiners Island

Peaceful 3-bedroom house in East Hampton is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space, pool access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Peaceful 3-bedroom house in East Hampton

Peaceful 3-bedroom house in East Hampton is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space, pool access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, pet friendly, pets friendly, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $11,139.

From$1,178/night
Show
BlackBerry Private home with jacuzzi yearlong - Gardiners Island, NY

BlackBerry Private home with jacuzzi yearlong

Holiday Home, Gardiners Island

BlackBerry Private home with jacuzzi yearlong is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing…

Read more

About BlackBerry Private home with jacuzzi yearlong

BlackBerry Private home with jacuzzi yearlong is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with pet-friendly space. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: hot tub, free wifi, pet friendly, and pets friendly.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $11,967.

From$1,216/night
Show

Best Gardiners Island, NY vacation rentals with a kitchen

Compare stays with kitchen access for longer trips and easier meals.

PERFECT, BEAUTIFULLY NEWLY DESIGNED 1,000 FT. MONTAUK OCEANFRT 3-LEVEL TOWNHOUSE - Gardiners Island, NY

PERFECT, BEAUTIFULLY NEWLY DESIGNED 1,000 FT. MONTAUK OCEANFRT 3-LEVEL TOWNHOUSE

Condo, Gardiners Island

PERFECT, BEAUTIFULLY NEWLY DESIGNED 1,000 FT. MONTAUK OCEANFRT 3-LEVEL TOWNHOUSE is a condo in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About PERFECT, BEAUTIFULLY NEWLY DESIGNED 1,000 FT. MONTAUK OCEANFRT 3-LEVEL TOWNHOUSE

PERFECT, BEAUTIFULLY NEWLY DESIGNED 1,000 FT. MONTAUK OCEANFRT 3-LEVEL TOWNHOUSE is a condo in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, beachfront, and beach front.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $6,212.

From$655/night
Show
Driftwood Resort - Gardiners Island, NY

Driftwood Resort

Condo, Gardiners Island

Driftwood Resort is a condo in Gardiners Island, with pool access and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and…

Read more

About Driftwood Resort

Driftwood Resort is a condo in Gardiners Island, with pool access and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, free wifi, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $6,069.

From$730/night
Show
Beautiful House with Private Beach Access - Rental Registry Cert #23-1,120 - Gardiners Island, NY

Beautiful House with Private Beach Access - Rental Registry Cert #23-1,120

Holiday Home, Gardiners Island

Beautiful House with Private Beach Access - Rental Registry Cert #23-1,120 is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Beautiful House with Private Beach Access - Rental Registry Cert #23-1,120

Beautiful House with Private Beach Access - Rental Registry Cert #23-1,120 is a holiday home in Gardiners Island, with easy beach access and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, and gym.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,399.

From$810/night
Show
Unit 711: Two-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Dune View | Sand Dollar - Gardiners Island, NY

Unit 711: Two-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Dune View | Sand Dollar

Apartment, Gardiners Island

Unit 711: Two-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Dune View · Sand Dollar is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with parking, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About Unit 711: Two-Bedroom | 1st Floor-Dune View | Sand Dollar

Unit 711: Two-Bedroom · 1st Floor-Dune View · Sand Dollar is a apartment in Gardiners Island, with parking, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, parking, onsite parking, and washer.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $8,641.

From$865/night
Show