Vacation rentals in Butterfield Lake, NY

Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Butterfield Lake, NY

MacAlister Cottage, MacAlister Cottage at Camp Caledonia

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

MacAlister Cottage, MacAlister Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About MacAlister Cottage, MacAlister Cottage at Camp Caledonia

MacAlister Cottage, MacAlister Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, pet friendly, pets friendly, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $729.

From$70/night

Show›

MacFarlane Cottage, MacFarlane Cottage at Camp Caledonia

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

MacFarlane Cottage, MacFarlane Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About MacFarlane Cottage, MacFarlane Cottage at Camp Caledonia

MacFarlane Cottage, MacFarlane Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, pet friendly, pets friendly, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $729.

From$70/night

Show›

MacKenzie Cottage, MacKenzie Cottage at Camp Caledonia

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

MacKenzie Cottage, MacKenzie Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About MacKenzie Cottage, MacKenzie Cottage at Camp Caledonia

MacKenzie Cottage, MacKenzie Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, pet friendly, pets friendly, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $729.

From$70/night

Show›

MacPherson Cottage, MacPherson Cottage at Camp Caledonia

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

MacPherson Cottage, MacPherson Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About MacPherson Cottage, MacPherson Cottage at Camp Caledonia

MacPherson Cottage, MacPherson Cottage at Camp Caledonia is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, pet friendly, pets friendly, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $729.

From$70/night

Show›

Browse Waterfront Vacation Rentals in Butterfield Lake, NY

Discover vacation rentals close to the coast, water, and beach areas around Butterfield Lake, NY.

2 BR Lakefront Apartment on Black Lake

Apartment, Butterfield Lake

2 BR Lakefront Apartment on Black Lake is a apartment in Butterfield Lake, with parking, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the…

Read more

About 2 BR Lakefront Apartment on Black Lake

2 BR Lakefront Apartment on Black Lake is a apartment in Butterfield Lake, with parking, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, and parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $1,664.

From$177/night

Show›

Tranquil lake front cabin on Black Lake

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Tranquil lake front cabin on Black Lake is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing…

Read more

About Tranquil lake front cabin on Black Lake

Tranquil lake front cabin on Black Lake is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, and parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $2,369.

From$254/night

Show›

Thousand Island Area - St. Lawrence River Waterfront COZY Cottage

Cottage, Butterfield Lake

Thousand Island Area - St. Lawrence River Waterfront COZY Cottage is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a…

Read more

About Thousand Island Area - St. Lawrence River Waterfront COZY Cottage

Thousand Island Area - St. Lawrence River Waterfront COZY Cottage is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: hot tub, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and free parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $2,793.

From$296/night

Show›

Elegant Chalet Style, Large Deck, Huge Spacious Green Yard, Riverfront

Chalet, Butterfield Lake

Elegant Chalet Style, Large Deck, Huge Spacious Green Yard, Riverfront is a chalet in Butterfield Lake, with outdoor space and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base…

Read more

About Elegant Chalet Style, Large Deck, Huge Spacious Green Yard, Riverfront

Elegant Chalet Style, Large Deck, Huge Spacious Green Yard, Riverfront is a chalet in Butterfield Lake, with outdoor space and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, fireplace, and washer.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $1,961.

From$225/night

Show›

Best Butterfield Lake, NY vacation rentals with parking

Find vacation rentals that make arriving by car easier.

Newly Renovated Bright & Cozy Retreat

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Newly Renovated Bright & Cozy Retreat is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with parking, kitchen access, and a quieter setting. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring…

Read more

About Newly Renovated Bright & Cozy Retreat

Newly Renovated Bright & Cozy Retreat is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with parking, kitchen access, and a quieter setting. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and free parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $2,374.

From$266/night

Show›

Nearley New Lakefront Cabin - Lake of The Isles

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Nearley New Lakefront Cabin - Lake of The Isles is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area,…

Read more

About Nearley New Lakefront Cabin - Lake of The Isles

Nearley New Lakefront Cabin - Lake of The Isles is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with parking and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and free parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,103.

From$446/night

Show›

Alexandria Bay, Schooner’s on the Bay, perfect Walk to everything, on the water

Cottage, Butterfield Lake

Alexandria Bay, Schooner’s on the Bay, perfect Walk to everything, on the water is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives…

Read more

About Alexandria Bay, Schooner’s on the Bay, perfect Walk to everything, on the water

Alexandria Bay, Schooner’s on the Bay, perfect Walk to everything, on the water is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, parking, and free parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,569.

From$504/night

Show›

Charming Waterfront House with Detached Cabin

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Charming Waterfront House with Detached Cabin is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Charming Waterfront House with Detached Cabin

Charming Waterfront House with Detached Cabin is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: kitchen, with kitchen, parking, free parking, and fireplace.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $7,828.

From$850/night

Show›

Best Pet-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Butterfield Lake, NY

Bring your pet along with stays that welcome four-legged travelers.

The Lookout- Renovations and upgrades coming

Cabin, Butterfield Lake

The Lookout- Renovations and upgrades coming is a cabin in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space and pool access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area,…

Read more

About The Lookout- Renovations and upgrades coming

The Lookout- Renovations and upgrades coming is a cabin in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space and pool access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: pool, free wifi, pet friendly, and pets friendly.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $2,604.

From$277/night

Show›

Downtown Alex Bay home- Newly Renovated!

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Downtown Alex Bay home- Newly Renovated! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Downtown Alex Bay home- Newly Renovated!

Downtown Alex Bay home- Newly Renovated! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and parking. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, pet friendly, pets friendly, parking, and free parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $3,465.

From$379/night

Show›

Waterfront Home On Grenadier Island With Private Dock

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Waterfront Home On Grenadier Island With Private Dock is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space and easy beach access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Waterfront Home On Grenadier Island With Private Dock

Waterfront Home On Grenadier Island With Private Dock is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space and easy beach access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, hot tub, free wifi, pet friendly, and pets friendly.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $3,724.

From$392/night

Show›

Dog-Friendly large rural Estate just outside Alex Bay with hot tub and pool!

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Dog-Friendly large rural Estate just outside Alex Bay with hot tub and pool! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, pool access, and easy beach access. This stay…

Read more

About Dog-Friendly large rural Estate just outside Alex Bay with hot tub and pool!

Dog-Friendly large rural Estate just outside Alex Bay with hot tub and pool! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, pool access, and easy beach access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, pool, hot tub, and free wifi.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,602.

From$497/night

Show›

Best Butterfield Lake, NY vacation rentals with a kitchen

Compare stays with kitchen access for longer trips and easier meals.

Private Island // Best views of the 1000 Islands!

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Private Island // Best views of the 1000 Islands! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing…

Read more

About Private Island // Best views of the 1000 Islands!

Private Island // Best views of the 1000 Islands! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, kitchen, with kitchen, fireplace, and washer.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,162.

From$440/night

Show›

Kings' Landing Cottage in the Thousand Islands

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Kings' Landing Cottage in the Thousand Islands is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring…

Read more

About Kings' Landing Cottage in the Thousand Islands

Kings' Landing Cottage in the Thousand Islands is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, pet friendly, pets friendly, and kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $4,801.

From$509/night

Show›

Luxury Cottage in Alex Bay 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths. Book your 2026 Vacation Now!!

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Luxury Cottage in Alex Bay 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths. Book your 2026 Vacation Now!! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, kitchen access, and room for a group. This…

Read more

About Luxury Cottage in Alex Bay 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths. Book your 2026 Vacation Now!!

Luxury Cottage in Alex Bay 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths. Book your 2026 Vacation Now!! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, and kids friendly.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $5,598.

From$617/night

Show›

Luxury Waterfront Cottage 1000 Islands 6 BR, 4.5 Baths Book your 2026 vacation!

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Luxury Waterfront Cottage 1000 Islands 6 BR, 4.5 Baths Book your 2026 vacation! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, kitchen access, and room for a group. This…

Read more

About Luxury Waterfront Cottage 1000 Islands 6 BR, 4.5 Baths Book your 2026 vacation!

Luxury Waterfront Cottage 1000 Islands 6 BR, 4.5 Baths Book your 2026 vacation! is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, kitchen access, and room for a group. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, and gym.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $10,636.

From$1,170/night

Show›

Our Favorite Family-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Butterfield Lake, NY

Plan a trip with stays that give families more room to spread out.

Unique Historic Boathouse on a Stunning Private Island in the 1000 Islands

Cottage, Butterfield Lake

Unique Historic Boathouse on a Stunning Private Island in the 1000 Islands is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Unique Historic Boathouse on a Stunning Private Island in the 1000 Islands

Unique Historic Boathouse on a Stunning Private Island in the 1000 Islands is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, pet friendly, pets friendly, and kids friendly.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $1,901.

From$220/night

Show›

Waterfront cottage with a beautiful view

Cottage, Butterfield Lake

Waterfront cottage with a beautiful view is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for…

Read more

About Waterfront cottage with a beautiful view

Waterfront cottage with a beautiful view is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, pet friendly, pets friendly, and kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $2,126.

From$236/night

Show›

Cozy Cottage on Quiet Street – Walk to Beach & Downtown

Holiday Home, Butterfield Lake

Cozy Cottage on Quiet Street – Walk to Beach & Downtown is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable…

Read more

About Cozy Cottage on Quiet Street – Walk to Beach & Downtown

Cozy Cottage on Quiet Street – Walk to Beach & Downtown is a holiday home in Butterfield Lake, with easy beach access, parking, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free cancellation, free wifi, kitchen, with kitchen, and parking.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $2,387.

From$259/night

Show›

Relax, Enjoy and Unwind on the Lake at Goose Bay Cottage - Pet Friendly!

Cottage, Butterfield Lake

Relax, Enjoy and Unwind on the Lake at Goose Bay Cottage - Pet Friendly! is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives…

Read more

About Relax, Enjoy and Unwind on the Lake at Goose Bay Cottage - Pet Friendly!

Relax, Enjoy and Unwind on the Lake at Goose Bay Cottage - Pet Friendly! is a cottage in Butterfield Lake, with pet-friendly space, easy beach access, and kitchen access. This stay gives travelers a comfortable base for exploring the area, relaxing between outings, and spending time with family or friends.

Useful features: free wifi, pet friendly, pets friendly, kitchen, and with kitchen.

Sat, Aug 29 - Sat, Sep 5 · 7 nights · total from $3,222.

From$345/night

Show›